Could Guy Berthault Conduct a New Experiment, Please?

Assorted retorts from yahoo boards and elsewhere : Gutsick Gibbon on Cross Disciplinarity Outlawed in Academia, Heat Problem, Gate-Keeping · Gutsick Gibbon's Five Points Answered, I, Heat Problem and Extra on Absence of Solutions As Criterium · Gutsick Gibbon on Overturning Paradigms and Castile Formation · Geologic Column : Absent from Land Vertebrate Palaeontology · Continuing with Kevin · Creation vs. Evolution : Could Guy Berthault Conduct a New Experiment, Please? · Correspondence of Hans Georg Lundahl : Correspondence with Gutsick Gibbon (Erika) and with Kevin R. Henke

For solid bodies only when they are swept away by muddy water, Guy Berthault on Sedimentology.fr has already done what is needed.

Video25
7th Dec. 2006 | xytorix
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MHPZ0pnPmHs

(Video for site http://geology.ref.ac/berthault/)

I have been told by Kevin R. Henke that this is useless for Castile and Green River Formations, and his reason given is, these involve chemical precipitates.

However, the end result involves substances that can all of them be found now.

Here are two solutions proposed, which can be tested by someone trained to do that, which I am not.

But first two principles, as I (an utter amateur) see them:

• in general, Berthault's explanation is adequate for explaining sediment wharves;
• before deposits become sandstone, there is some kind of chemical expanasion of the silicates, and expulsion of the water.

Here are then the proposed solutions, I will call them "Berthault" and "Berthault cum Heerema" - the latter after a Dutch engineer who has given his view.

I "Berthault"

Grains of gypsum and calcite or that can become such, as well as pollen, must be hydrostatically sorted by salt water.

End result must involve wharves, pollen in some of them, fine laminated layers of salt, gypsum, calcite. The process by which grains of silicate join to sandstone should here be parallel to how sorted gypsum and calcite make layers, and it should expel salt water to even more laminae in between, and these should then form layers of solid rock salt.

II "Berthault cum Heerema"

Here the sorting would involve electrostatic (?) sorting, since gypsum and calcite or what becomes such would, quite as much as the salt, be dissolved in the water. Kevin R. Henke has presented one of the formations, I didn't quite get which one, as forming a long stretch of 113 km. That would be a Berthault flume, but for electrostatic sorting, it would be adequate with a volcanic eruption further up or further down that stream, since salt water would be a good conductor and lead electricity from the eruption to the 113 km we are here discussing. Obviously, instead of a volcano, Berthault is perfectly authorised to use a more normal source of electric one way current or discharges.

Hans Georg Lundahl
Paris
St. Scholastica
10.II.2022

Apud montem Cassinum sanctae Scholasticae Virginis, sororis sancti Benedicti Abbatis, qui ejus animam, instar columbae, migrantem e corpore in caelum ascendere vidit.