Tas Walker and Myself on C14 : Glacial Maximum and End · Interim III, Flood to Abraham with Syncellus · Continuing Interim III to Joseph in Egypt · Comparing Three Roads from Seven Cows to Seven Trumpets
How do we do that?
Well, for one thing, we know the Joseph in Egypt episode is misdated to whenever Djoser is misdated to, since Joseph according to hunger stele was in all probability Imhotep.
Then we look for a clue when Joseph would have been there according to Syncellus.
2189 BC Birth of Abraham
0075 (take away)
2114 BC Promise to Abraham
0430 (take away)
1684 BC Exodus after promise = 1685 BC, Exodus acc to Syncellus
0215 (add back)
1899 BC Jacob to Egypt c. about time when Pharao Djoser is going to die.
Interim III ended on:
- XXIX 2208 BC
- 86.572 pmc 3400 BC
2208
1899
0307 : 8 = 38.375 (actually 309, sorry!)
| XXIX 2208 | XXX 2170 | XXXI 2131 | ||
| XXXII 2093 | XXXIII 2055 | XXXIV 2016 | ||
| XXXV 1978 | XXXVI 1939 | XXXVII 1901 |
1900 BC, misdated as 2800 crude C-14 year (Djoser redated on historical grounds to 2600 BC).
This is 900 extra years.
1192
0900
0292 : 8 = 36.5 extra years
| XXIX 1192 | XXX 1155.5 | XXXI 1119 | ||
| XXXII 1082.5 | XXXIII 1046 | XXXIV 1009.5 | ||
| XXXV 973 | XXXVI 936.5 | XXXVII 900 |
This means what in percent modern carbon (pmc)?
| XXIX 86.572 pmc | XXX 86.955 pmc | XXXI 87.34 pmc | ||
| XXXII 87.726 pmc | XXXIII 88.115 pmc | XXXIV 88.504 pmc | ||
| XXXV 88.896 pmc | XXXVI 89.289 pmc | XXXVII 89.685 pmc |
And which are the "apparent years"?
| XXIX 3400 | XXX 3325 | XXXI 3250 | ||
| XXXII 3175 | XXXIII 3101 | XXXIV 3025 | ||
| XXXV 2951 | XXXVI 2875 | XXXVII 2801 |
Let's make a table, inserting our previous knowledge too:
- I 3358 BC
- 1.514 pmc 38 000 BC
- Arphaxad *
- 3356 BC
- II 3317 BC
- 1.962 pmc 35 815 BC
- III 3276 BC
- 2.543 pmc 33 631 BC
- IV 3235 BC
- 3.295 pmc 31 446 BC
- Cainan *
- 3223 BC
- V 3194 BC
- 4.271 pmc 29 262 BC
- VI 3153 BC
- 5.535 pmc 27 077 BC
- VII 3112 BC
- 7.173 pmc 24 892 BC
- Shelah *
- 3093 BC
- VIII 3070 BC
- 9.297 pmc 22 708 BC
- IX 3029 BC
- 12.049 pmc 20 523 BC
- Noah +
- 3008 BC
- X 2988 BC
- 15.616 pmc 18 338 BC
- Eber *
- 2963 BC
- XI 2947 BC
- 20.239 pmc 16 154 BC
- XII 2906 BC
- 26.23 pmc 13 969 BC
- XIII 2865 BC
- 33.994 pmc 11 785 BC
- Shem +
- 2858 BC
- Peleg *
- 2829 BC
- XIV 2824 BC
- 44.057 pmc 9600 BC
- Arphaxad +
- 2791 BC
- XV 2780 BC
- 49.459 pmc 8600 BC
- Cainan +
- 2763 BC
- XVI 2739 BC
- 51.476 pmc 8229 BC
- Reu *
- 2699 BC
- XVII 2698 BC
- 53.577 pmc 7857 BC
- XVIII 2657 BC
- 55.763 pmc 7486 BC
- Shelah +
- 2633 BC
- XIX 2617 BC
- 58.038 pmc 7114 BC
- XX 2576 BC
- 60.405 pmc 6743 BC
- Serug *
- 2567 BC
- XXI 2535 BC
- 62.87 pmc 6371 BC
- XXII 2494 BC
- 65.435 pmc 6000 BC
- Peleg +
- 2490 BC
- Eber +
- 2459 BC
- XXIII 2453 BC
- 68.105 pmc 5629 BC
- Nahor *
- 2437 BC
- XXIV 2412 BC
- 70.883 pmc 5257 BC
- XXV 2371 BC
- 73.775 pmc 4886 BC
- Reu +
- 2360 BC
- Terah *
- 2358 BC
- XXVI 2331 BC
- 76.785 pmc 4514 BC
- XXVII 2290 BC
- 79.918 pmc 4143 BC
- Abraham *
- 2288 BC
- XXVIII 2249 BC
- 83.178 pmc 3771 BC
- Serug +
- 2237 BC
- Nahor +
- 2229 BC
- XXIX 2208 BC
- 86.572 pmc 3400 BC
- Isaac *
- 2188 BC
- XXX 2170 BC
- 86.955 pmc : 3325 BC
- Terah +
- 2153 BC
- XXXI 2131 BC
- 87.34 pmc : 3250 BC
- Jacob and Esau *
- 2128 BC
- Abraham +
- 2113 BC
- XXXII 2093 BC
- 87.726 pmc : 3175 BC
- XXXIII 2055 BC
- 88.115 pmc : 3101 BC
- XXXIV 2016 BC
- 88.504 pmc : 3025 BC
- Isaac +
- 2008 BC
Jacob +1981 BC - ERROR WHERE?
- XXXV 1978 BC
- 88.896 pmc : 2951 BC
- XXXVI 1939 BC
- 89.289 pmc : 2875
- XXXVII 1901 BC
- 89.685 pmc : 2801
- Jacob +
- 1881 BC
I seem to have come to an impass with the chronology, it seems Jacob dies way too early in relation to his arrival in Egypt.
Hans Georg Lundahl
Nanterre UL
St. Juliana Falconieri
Sister of the Servite Founder
19.VI.2017
PS, note very well that if this is an error in Syncellus and not in my understanding of him, there is no such paradox in St Jerome:
2015 Abraham born (acc. to Christmas chronology)
1915 Isaac born (when his father was 100)
1855 Jacob born (when his father was 60)
1725 Jacob to Egypt (at 130 years of age)
0215
1510 Exodus (acc. to Christmas chronology)
All years BC./HGL
PPS, Error fixed, simply subtraction error in year of when Jacob died./HGL
Aucun commentaire:
Enregistrer un commentaire