On the less likely "St Jerome B version", Tower of Babel dispersion event is as far from Flood as in Georgius Syncellus, and therefore closer to Abraham instead. It would have been in 2424 BC.
To explain, St Jerome's Christmas chronology quoted from Roman Martyrology in itself does not state anything about Tower of Babel. So, to me, where St Jerome's chronology placed that event is somewhat mysterious.
Extra years if end of Göbekli Tepe is the dispersion of tongues at Tower of Babel, 6176 of them, makes for a carbon level 47.374 pmc. Levels for 2957 (Flood) and 1928 (Abraham in En-Gedi) as previous.
- 2957 BC
- 1.636 pmc, + 34000 years, 36957 BC
- 2921 BC
- 11.75 pmc, + 17700 years, 20621 BC
- 2886 BC
- 19.592 pmc, + 13500 years, 16386 BC
- 2850 BC
- 25.842 pmc, + 11200 years, 14050 BC
- 2815 BC
- 30.689 pmc, + 9750 years, 12565 BC
- 2779 BC
- 34.552 pmc, + 8800 years, 11579 BC
- 2744 BC
- 37.548 pmc, + 8100 years, 10844 BC
- 2708 BC
- 39.935 pmc, + 7600 years, 10308 BC
- 2673 BC
- 41.786 pmc, + 7200 years, 9873 BC
- 2637 BC
- 43.262 pmc, + 6950 years, 9587 BC
- 2602 BC
- 44.407 pmc, + 6700 years, 9302 BC
- 2566 BC
- 45.318 pmc, + 6550 years, 9116 BC
- 2531 BC
- 46.023 pmc, + 6400 years, 8931 BC
- 2495 BC
- 46.589 pmc, + 6300 years, 8795 BC
- 2460 BC
- 47.029 pmc, + 6250 years, 8710 BC
- 2424 BC
- 47.374 pmc, + 6200 years, 8624 BC
Here the formula for pmc was a series of phi related values multiplied by the specific : ( 47.374 - 1.636 ) / 22.245
=2.05610249494268374915711395819285232636547538773,
add back 1.636.
Note that the table shows the years for Göbekli Tepe as being 2637 to 2424 BC, corresponding to 9587 to 9624 BC. 213 years of building activity, like Israel in Egypt.
Now the formula will be same series with the other specific here: ( 83.689 - 47.374 ) / 22.245
=1.63250168577208361429534726904922454484153742414026,
add back 47.374.
- 2424 BC
- 47.374 pmc, + 6200 years, 8624 BC
- 2391 BC
- 55.404 pmc, + 4900 years, 7291 BC
- 2358 BC
- 61.631 pmc, + 4000 years, 6358 BC
- 2325 BC
- 66.593 pmc, + 3350 years, 5675 BC
- 2292 BC
- 70.441 pmc, + 2900 years, 5192 BC
- 2259 BC
- 73.509 pmc, + 2550 years, 4809 BC
- 2226 BC
- 75.887 pmc, + 2300 years, 4526 BC
- 2193 BC
- 77.783 pmc, + 2100 years, 4293 BC
- 2159 BC
- 79.252 pmc, + 1900 years, 4059 BC
- 2126 BC
- 80.424 pmc, + 1800 years, 3926 BC
- 2093 BC
- 81.333 pmc, + 1700 years, 3793 BC
- 2060 BC
- 82.056 pmc, + 1650 years, 3710 BC
- 2027 BC
- 82.616 pmc, + 1600 years, 3627 BC
- 1994 BC
- 83.065 pmc, + 1550 years, 3544 BC
- 1961 BC
- 83.415 pmc, + 1500 years, 3461 BC
- 1928 BC
- 83.689 pmc, + 1450 years, 3378 BC
If you feel this one is more likely than the other one, feel free to use it instead.
If you feel Ziggurat of Ur is a better match than Göbekli Tepe for Tower of Babel project, feel free to use that one for 2424 BC. There is a problem with that.
Ziggurat of Ur is supposed to have been built by Ur-Nammu, and perhaps there is even some evidence to back that up. And Ur-Nammu is a bit too late:
Ur-Nammu (conventional) 2112–c. 2095 (short chronology) 2047–2030 BC.
Sumerian had already been spoken and written for some while and if these dates were to date like 2424 BC, well, the pmc of atmosphere would have been around 99% already - way too high for so early, if one is to date Abraham in En Gedi as ... Chalcolithic of En Gedi.
So, to me, Ziggurat of Ur is out of the question as "Tower of Babel" project. Note also that Ur was not abandoned after the Ziggurat. This means buildings would have been added to Ur after the Ziggurat. And this means if the Ziggurat had been the tower of Babel, the text would be wrong, where it says "and they ceased to build the city" (Genesis 11:8b).
Obviously, it is not.
Ur is not the city which they were building.
But other end of Shinar, Göbekli Tepe could be the abandoned city, with 18 km (12 miles?) to Urfa, a k a Edessa. A city then begun after Göbekli Tepe was abandoned (see Genesis 11:8) and which could be Ur Kasdim.
I look at the years here, I think 2424 is late for Göbekli Tepe. With 2424 you have GT starting 213 years earlier, according to the curve. I think St Jerome A is a better alternative, or Georgius Syncellus. I have not yet looked at St Jerome C.
Hans Georg Lundahl
Nanterre UL
Ember Wednesday
of Lent
8.III.2017
PS, nearly forgot to credit my good calculating helps, the online calcuilator here:
http://web2.0calc.com/
and the carbon 14 calculator here:
https://www.math.upenn.edu/~deturck/m170/c14/carbdate.html
with short link: http://ppt.li/3m8
Aucun commentaire:
Enregistrer un commentaire